The “Great Qin Fu” being played on TV is really a hot mess, and although the score on Douban is gradually declining, there is more and more talk about this drama.
The actual Hong Kong, if purely from the TV production level, in the domestic drama, this is counted as a strong cast, filming technology, narrative tight works.
In addition to the efforts made in the selection of actors and scriptwriters, the war scenes of this film were also shot with great momentum, very realistic, and did not spend less money.
Although the actors were well found and money was not spent, the drama was still met with a lot of criticism.
Some of them said that they made up the history and changed it, and changed the phrase “Although Chu has three households, the death of Qin will be Chu” to “Although Chu has three households, the death of Qin will be Chu”. The “three households of Chu, the surrender of Qin will be Chu. “
There are also people who say that this film glorifies violence, the Qin dynasty died in the second century, mainly because tyranny is not popular, but this play, but the “Qin people do not have time to mourn themselves, and later people mourned”, rewritten as “Qin people do not have time to mourn themselves, and later people do praise of”.
In the face of so much criticism, how did the director of “The Great Qin Fugue” take a stand?
According to TV Cat, the director of the film, Yan Yi, said “The effort we made for the play “The Great Qin Fugue” is to inspire people…to die generously for the country…this is the soul of the play, the root. “
Can be said to be very positive energy, nowadays, anything as long as the patriotic a hook, it is the same as into the safe. You then want to criticize him, the light will be said to be negative energy, serious point, “hate the country party” and The “traitor” hat will give you buckle over.
Of course, there is nothing wrong with being patriotic, but the question is whose country do you want to love? What kind of country do you love?
If it is love of Qin, then the director is to call us to love the country that does not agree to “burn books and bury Confucius”, in order to completely combat the opponent’s momentum, saving food can be hundreds of thousands of soldiers have surrendered all buried alive.
If this is the only way to be patriotic, then Chen Sheng, Wu Guang, and even Liu Bang and Xiang Yu, would not they be rebellious and thieves? If they are not to be executed, they should at least be sentenced to provocation and harassment, right?
In 2005, The Japanese NHK had a famous interview when they asked some random people on the street: “Would you like to die for your country? A young Japanese man’s answer was later made famous when he said, “A country that wants its people to die for it would be better to die sooner. “
What this young man said was in stark contrast to what the director of “The Great Qin Fugue” said.
He incidentally also made it clear that the Qin dynasty was finished after two generations, not because the people did not love it, but only because Qin Shi Huang’s brutality had buried itself.
The tyranny of Qin Shi Huang’s weak people is graphically depicted in the famous article “On the Passage of Qin”.
“abolished the way of the previous king, burned the words of a hundred schools, to fool the Qian; overthrow the famous city, kill the heroes; collect the world’s troops, gathered in Xianyang, pin the frontier dysprosium, cast for the gold people twelve, to weaken the people of the world”.
In contemporary times, Li Jingheng’s research on the unearthed Qin briefs shows that
The Qin dynasty is the world’s largest and most populous nation, with a population of about 2,000. \
This death rate, only the Nazi concentration camps can be compared to him.
And this is just the tip of the iceberg of Qin Shi Huang’s tyranny.
Some of my friends say that since the director likes to die for his country so much, when they need to die, let them go first. This statement is a bit mean, we can take it as a kind of flirtation, but also a bit of truth.
If it is in the war against Japan, when the national tragedy, of course, to die for the country is a kind of glory.
But do not forget that the Japanese militarists at the time also called on the people to engage in “100 million people total jade shattering”, that is a disgrace in the history of human civilization, even today’s Japanese have long thought that is a two-faced behavior.
Qin Shi Huang and the Qin dynasty in the end is a kind of, I hope the “Qin Fu” director heart a little B number, otherwise you this kind of persuasion for the tyrant to die, I’m afraid it will also become a “XX billion people total jade broken”.
There is nothing wrong with making a TV series to make some money, but it is very disgusting to have to fight under the banner of patriotism to rehabilitate the stinking tyranny.
Recent Comments